How real a threat is Abu Bakar to South Asian masculinity?
On International Men's Day, we look at what a fictional Pakistani drama character tells us about the discussion surrounding what it means to be a good man
In the 2008 Hindi romance film, Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi, the guileless hero played by Shah Rukh Khan is befuddled when the woman he’s hopelessly in love with (his wife, mind you) tells him no girl wants a man who goes around acting macho. This conflicts with what his male friend has been teaching him about wooing women. What do girls actually want, then? “The answer,” his wife says, “is simple, but by the time a boy figures it out, both will have grown old.”
A cursory glance through social media last month after Episode 24 of the Pakistani drama Dar-e-Nijaat dropped on ARY Digital’s Youtube channel would find that a large swath of man-boys across South Asia has indeed not figured out what women actually want (and likely never will). The subject of their disgruntled posts? A character by the name of Abu Bakar.
Abu Bakar is rich and highly qualified. Abu Bakar is handsome, physically fit, has luscious, perfectly coiffed wavy hair and a unique sense of style. The man-boys griping about the spell this fictional man has cast over their wives tend to get hung up on the superficial
Abu Bakar is rich and highly qualified. Abu Bakar is handsome, physically fit, has luscious, perfectly coiffed wavy hair and a unique sense of style. The man-boys griping about the spell this fictional man has cast over their wives tend to get hung up on the superficial. They either willfully ignore or perhaps are incapable of grasping that Abu Bakar is also well-spoken, emotionally intelligent, gentle and kind. Abu Bakar will not tolerate any slander against his wife, Zaryab. Abu Bakar will fan the sexual tension between them, but make do with a chaste kiss to Zaryab’s hand until he earns her full consent, because Abu Bakar’s respect, loyalty and duty as a husband are not contingent on her love, labour or the promise of sex.
One middle-aged Facebook user commented, “… after hearing all the descriptions from my wife, it appears that he is a man with no real guts” – because if you can’t assert your dominance over your unwilling wife, can you really call yourself a man? South Asian media has been rife with toxic masculinity since time immemorial.
So-called “heroes” are allowed to be irredeemable, women are objectified and debased, eve-teasing is passed off as flirting, stalking as devotion, and partner violence as passion. Over the last decade or so, movies like Toofan, Borbaad, Animal, Kabir Singh and Dhurandhar have peddled an alpha-male fantasy that marries this toxic masculinity with ultra-stylized graphic violence and a confounding disregard for personal grooming. Their shock value has successfully held audiences in thrall for years. So, naturally, it comes as a shock to many that a decent, clean-shaven gentleman without the usual blood-soaked bells and whistles could have the cultural impact that he’s had.
Scroll through Instagram every Friday and Saturday and you’ll find Abu Bakar being embraced by women and men alike. Mixed gender friend groups are cheering him on at watch parties, teenage boys are too distracted by the show’s slow-burn romance to study for their exams, stoic uncles are giggling and kicking their feet, and male influencers are recreating Abu Bakar’s wardrobe. On Facebook, one man writes, “Shongshar shukhi hoy Abu Bakar’der guun-e” (Marriages thrive on the virtues of Abu Bakars). Far from being resentful or acerbic, these boys and men exude an infectious sense of delight, not just at being heavily invested in the fate of Zaryab and Abu Bakar’s romance, but at being able to share this cultural phenomenon with the women in their lives.
Though they have yet to watch Dar-e-Nijaal, the men in my own life have been much the same. Going back to 2008, when my family lived in New Delhi, my father took my mother and I to see Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi opening weekend. He loved and identified with Shah Rukh Khan’s Abu Bakar variant so much he recommended the movie to everyone and bought the DVD when it came out. That same year, while home from college, my older brother, to my immense annoyance, planted himself next to me as I streamed a camera print of Twilight using my dial-up internet connection to see what all the fuss was about. He continues to be an avid consumer of romance media like Bridgerton, outwardly “to see what all the fuss is about,” but actually because he enjoys it.
So how big a threat, then, is romance media to the South Asian construct of masculinity? Does it really impose impossible standards on husbands as some allege? The boys and men enjoying Dar-e-Nijaal don’t seem to think so. In September, a Bangladeshi advocate’s High Court petition to ban the production and broadcast of romance films on grounds it degraded youth and encouraged social disorder was laughed off by most quarters, and most of the snide remarks about Abu Bakar seem to be coming from man-boys who haven’t actually watched the show but want the social media engagement.
'Unmarried girls can be presented with 99 Abu Bakars and they will still marry the 1 other'
“Unmarried girls can be presented with 99 Abu Bakars and they will still marry the 1 other,” writes one engagement farmer, the text slapped over a photo of himself for some reason. This rhetoric echoes a common strain in the manosphere – a segment of the internet the UN describes as, “a loose network of [online] communities that claim to address men’s struggles … but often promote harmful advice and attitudes [toward women]” – that insists women will only date the top 20% men – an entirely arbitrary figure with no statistical basis. Perpetuated by podcast personas like Andrew Tate and radical clerics, the manosphere brainwashes an ever-growing number of men into believing that feminism is the root of all their problems, that they are the nice guys who finish last because they’re not wealthy or good looking enough, and that the only way to rectify this is by “leveling up” and being macho.
If Abu Bakar has achieved anything, it has been to lay bare the divide between masculinity and machismo. He has gifted us a glimpse at the tenderness and humor boys and men are capable of while simultaneously riling the radicalized. He is also a stark reminder of the power mass media commands over South Asian audiences – proof that counter-programming to gory, misogynist, testosterone-fueled action films can be just as successful.
Romance media might even have the power to deradicalize the man-boys. We are, after all, talking about a people who, for three long decades, deified Shah Rukh Khan not for being the action star he is today, but for being the likeable, seemingly attainable romantic hero every woman once wanted for herself, and every man aspired to be.
Noor Juman is a romance author and a policy consultant.