Sheikh Hasina says she will return to Bangladesh in December “at any cost.” On November 9, she requested a new passport and national identity card. Dhaka rejected that request and said it wants her extradited. A passport application sounds ordinary enough. Except the applicant has already been convicted in her absence and sentenced to death over the deadly crackdown on the 2024 uprising. There is rather more waiting for her than there is for immigration clearance. So, does she need a passport? Can Bangladesh bring her back without one? And how much say does India have?
No passport does not mean no return
There are two different ways this could happen: Hasina returns voluntarily, or India formally hands her over. For a voluntary return, Bangladesh can issue a travel permit to a citizen without a valid passport. But whether the authorities would give Hasina one cannot be assumed. The other route is extradition, in which one country hands someone over to another to face trial or serve a sentence. The India–Bangladesh treaty does not require that person to hold a valid passport. It requires documents establishing their identity and the legal grounds for bringing them back. So refusing Hasina a passport does not, by itself, block her extradition.
Then why can’t Bangladesh simply collect her?
Because a Bangladeshi arrest warrant does not give Bangladeshi police permission to enter India and arrest someone. Bangladesh must make a formal request through diplomatic channels. That request is assessed under the extradition treaty, signed in 2013 and amended in 2016, alongside India’s Extradition Act, 1962. The treaty sets the conditions for a handover; Indian law governs the steps Indian authorities take to carry it out. An arrest warrant from Bangladesh can support the request. But it cannot bypass India’s legal process.
Is India legally required to hand her over?
Yes, if the treaty’s conditions are met and no grounds for refusal apply. It is an obligation, but not an automatic approval. First, the conduct must be a crime in both countries, punishable by at least one year in prison. The legal term is “dual criminality,” which considers whether what she is accused of doing is also a crime in India. The offence does not need the same name in both countries. What matters is the conduct.
Does she have to have personally carried out the violence?
No. Article 2 covers aiding, abetting, inciting and participating as an accomplice. Its reach extends beyond the person who pulled the trigger to those who helped or encouraged the crime. So not personally firing a weapon does not, by itself, put someone beyond extradition. Hasina has already been convicted in Bangladesh for ordering the deadly attacks of July 2024.
Here is the irony: the process was simplified while Hasina was in power
In 2016, Bangladesh and India amended the treaty to facilitate extradition. Hasina was then prime minister. For an accused person, the amendment removed the earlier requirement to supply evidence sufficient to justify sending them to trial in the requested country. An arrest warrant and the other required documents could support the request. The process her government helped simplify could now be used to seek her own return.
Can India say, “This is politics”?
The treaty allows India to refuse extradition for an offence of a political character. But there is a significant catch: it specifically excludes murder, culpable homicide, kidnapping and unlawful detention, among other serious offences, from that category. Being a politician does not automatically turn a criminal case into a protected political offence. Nor does a connection to political events settle the question.
What about saying the case was brought to target her?
That is a different argument. Article 8 addresses the second issue. It denies extradition if the person establishes specified grounds showing that surrender would be unjust or oppressive, including an accusation not made in good faith in the interests of justice. In everyday language: Hasina could argue that the case brought against her was unjust, fake or biased. But making that claim is not enough. She would have to satisfy India that the treaty’s grounds for refusal apply.
How long could all this take?
There is no general treaty deadline requiring India to approve or reject a request. Indian authorities must follow the applicable procedures for arrest, judicial examination and surrender. If the handover is authorised, the governments arrange it. Bangladesh generally has one month to take the person away, unless Indian law permits a longer period. In other words, announcing “December” does not impose a December deadline on the legal process.
But is the treaty actually binding?
Yes. Both countries ratified it, and it entered into force on October 23, 2013. India must follow it in good faith. In international law, we call it “pacta sunt servanda” (agreements must be kept). That includes both the obligation to extradite when the conditions are met and the safeguards allowing refusal. Indian law allows the government to stop the handover if it believes the case is too minor, the request was made for an improper purpose, or handing the person over would be unfair or unwise for political or other reasons. But India must still honour its treaty obligations.
So, what is the passport request really worth?
Hasina may talk about coming home as though the remaining business is a passport renewal and a flight booking. But she is a convicted person facing a death sentence. If she is returned by extradition, it will be a formal handover to Bangladeshi authorities under the law.