HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
North America

Now comes the real fight

A House majority built on opposition to Trump gives the party leverage over war funding, immigration enforcement, and foreign aid. Turning that leverage into policy will be harder

DARREN HALSTEAD/UNSPLASH
BIONIC READING

The campaign that carried Democrats back into the House majority was not mainly about foreign policy or the fine print of immigration law. It was about the price of groceries, gas, and health insurance, and about a president whose standing with voters had slipped to record lows.

A Fox News poll in mid-October found that disapproval of Trump’s handling of inflation had reached a record 77 percent, his overall approval had fallen to 36 percent, and Democrats led the generic House ballot, 54 percent to 45 percent. Marist found a similar tilt among likely voters and noted that a plurality said their congressional vote was in opposition to the president.

That is the central fact about the majority Democrats now hold. It is a mandate to check Trump, built on frustration with the cost of living. It is a much less defined mandate on what to do with power once they have it.

The practical limits are plain. Republicans were widely expected to keep the Senate, and Trump retains his veto. What Democrats gain is not the ability to write policy but the ability to demand answers, to control the House’s share of the spending process, and to force votes that put Republicans on the record. Their first targets are the war with Iran, the immigration enforcement campaign, the president’s tariffs, and the fate of foreign aid.

A referendum and a warning

Democrats’ victory rested on four things. The first and largest was prices. Six in 10 voters in the Fox poll named cost of living their top economic worry, well ahead of government spending, jobs, tariffs, and taxes. House Democrats organized their affordability message around five working groups, on health care, housing, groceries and goods, gas and utilities, and caregiving, and tied rising costs to inflation stemming from the Iran war and other policies.

The second was a broad sour mood that fell hardest on the party in power. Congress’s approval rating stood at 15 percent, yet among voters who disliked both parties, Democrats led by 62 percent to 36 percent. Trump’s favorability among likely voters was 37 percent favorable and 59 percent unfavorable.

The third was a wider battlefield. Analysts said Democrats had expanded the map by capitalizing on the president’s unpopularity, leaving them needing only a handful of net seats. In the past, generic-ballot leads like the ones Democrats held have been associated with big gains: in 2006 and 2018, Democrats won the House after flipping at least 30 seats.

The fourth was enthusiasm, driven in part by the immigration enforcement campaign and its consequences.

There is a caveat. NPR’s analysis of its own poll warned of signs of trouble for Democrats on just how many seats they might win. A majority is not necessarily a wave, and a narrow one would constrain the party’s leaders more than they have publicly acknowledged.

Where Republicans stumbled

That is the argument Democrats and many independents make. Republicans disagree with much of it, and they have their own account of the election’s causes, which appears below. But the critics’ case has a coherent shape.

On the economy, they point first to the tariffs. The Supreme Court ruled 6 to 3 in February that the emergency-powers law the administration relied on does not authorize sweeping tariffs, in an opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts, The Tax Foundation estimated that more than $160 billion had been collected illegally, and it remains unclear whether businesses or consumers will get refunds. The replacement tariffs Trump imposed afterward also lost in federal court.

On the war, the critics note that it began Feb 28 without a vote of Congress, has cost an estimated $25 billion, and has pushed up food and fuel prices. Only one in four Americans told Reuters/Ipsos the conflict was worth its costs. Even some Republicans broke with the White House: four joined most Democrats in the Senate to pass a war powers resolution.

On governing, they note that the party’s stated agenda, as the House speaker described it, centered on cutting taxes and federal spending, while voters were asking about costs. Democrats pressed the point with attacks on the party’s Medicaid cuts, including new work requirements, and on the expiration of Affordable Care Act tax credits that left millions facing higher premiums.

And on immigration, which had been a Republican strength, they argue the administration’s tactics gave away an advantage.

The backlash over ICE

Nowhere did the politics shift as sharply as on immigration enforcement.

The administration began by sending officers into mostly Democratic-led cities, with visible operations in places like Chicago and Boston. Tom Homan, the White House border czar, said sanctuary cities should expect more activity in New York, Los Angeles, Portland and Seattle.

The turning point came in Minneapolis. A surge of federal agents there was followed by the killings of two American citizens: Renee Good, a mother of three, shot by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent, and Alex Pretti, in a separate episode. The White House then changed course, sending Mr Homan to take over the operation, ordering body cameras for federal agents in the field in Minneapolis, and moving the Border Patrol commander who had become the face of the effort out of the spotlight. Trump said he was recalibrating, not retreating.

Trump's hardline stance on immigration has met with severe disapprovalLEO VISIONS/UNSPLASH

The polls told a different story. Quinnipiac found 63 percent of voters disapproved of how ICE was enforcing immigration law, and 58 percent wanted Kristi Noem, the homeland security secretary, removed. A Fox News poll found a record 60 percent disapproval of the agency. The most consequential shift came among independents: their approval of Trump’s handling of immigration dropped from 37 percent in March 2025 to 23 percent, with roughly six in 10 saying he had gone too far. Even among Republicans, 30 percent said ICE was going too far, up 10 points in a week.

Democrats also pressed an economic argument. A Brookings analysis found that employment fell an average of 0.73 percent in the cities where ICE activity was most intense, and University of Colorado researchers estimated that for every undocumented man arrested, about six men left the work force.

The enforcement itself, however, did not stop. Arrests fell about 12 percent after the Minneapolis drawdown, then climbed again: ICE arrested 10,000 people over five days at the end of June. The agency had moved away from publicized city operations toward broader, less visible arrests nationwide. Critics of the administration describe this as a retreat from scrutiny, not from deportation.

That gives the new House Democrats an opening. They can summon Department of Homeland Security leaders, demand reporting on use of force and body camera compliance, press on data-sharing arrangements such as the sharing of Medicaid information with ICE, and attach conditions to homeland security spending.

They will meet resistance. Hard-liners argue the deportation numbers are still too low and want more worksite enforcement. Administration allies point to arrests of criminal offenders; one conservative outlet cited 10,000 gang members taken off the streets. And while a YouGov poll found 46 percent supported abolishing ICE against 41 percent opposed, most Democratic leaders avoid the slogan, wary of handing Republicans an easy line of attack.

War, tariffs, and aid

The foreign policy portfolio is where Democrats’ new power is most tangible, and most constrained. On Iran, the war powers resolution that passed was a concurrent resolution that does not go to the president for his signature, and the administration argues the War Powers Act is not binding and that American forces are not currently engaged in hostilities. That makes the power of the purse more important. The Wall Street Journal reported that Trump expects bombing to resume after the midterms, and the administration was expected to ask Congress for tens of billions of dollars more. House Democrats, who forced multiple votes on ending the conflict, plan more. A few Republicans have shown openness to a vote; Senator Susan Collins called the 60-day deadline “not a suggestion, it is a requirement.” Expect conditions on any war funding request and hearings on its costs and goals, not an outright cutoff.

On trade, Democrats’ 100-day plan includes measures to reverse the president’s tariffs. A veto-proof bill is out of reach, but a vote forces Republicans to take a position on prices. Tariffs on steel and aluminum, imposed under a different law, remain in place.

The race is on to reverse the president's tariffsIGOR OMILAEV/UNSPLASH

On Ukraine, diplomacy has stalled, with formal talks not resuming since the Iran operations began. The House can help protect the allied-financed transfers of American weapons, which had drawn more than $4.1 billion from partners by March.

In the Middle East, Gaza reconstruction is estimated to cost about $70 billion, giving Congress leverage to set conditions on humanitarian access and reporting. Lebanon is tied to the Iran track, since Tehran has linked any deal to a Hezbollah-Israel cease-fire and an Israeli withdrawal from southern Lebanon, and analysts have warned that a June framework could entrench a stalemate rather than end the war. The Democratic caucus is divided on how hard to press Israel, and leaders are likely to favor reporting requirements over cuts in aid.

On foreign aid, the case is cleaner. Congress, with Republican votes, passed $50.07 billion for State Department and national security programs in February. Yet reporting this summer found that the department has made little effort to spend money Congress earmarked for family planning, nutrition, and neglected tropical diseases. The department says it is not withholding funds. Because the appropriation was bipartisan, Democrats see an argument about Congress’s authority, not about foreign aid itself.

What a majority can do

Democratic leaders have been unusually specific about their opening moves. They plan to start within the first 100 hours after the new Congress is seated in January, with priorities that include restoring the expired health insurance tax credits and reversing Medicaid cuts. Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, who would become the first Democratic speaker since Nancy Pelosi, has also directed the senior Democrats on the Oversight and Judiciary Committees to prepare investigations of Trump, his family and his administration. On impeachment, he has said it is neither on nor off the table.

The calendar matters. Government funding runs only through Dec 11, and none of the regular spending bills for the current fiscal year had been enacted when the stopgap passed. The lame-duck Republican Congress can finish the bills, extend the deadline into 2027, risk a shutdown, or pass a full-year stopgap. A longer extension would push the central fight into the new Congress, when Democrats finally hold the House. Their leverage begins in January, not now.

The risks ahead

The constraints are real. Spending bills still need 60 votes in the Senate, and the veto remains. The caucus is split over Israel, tariffs, and how far to take immigration enforcement. A thin margin would make party discipline difficult, and the incoming class includes a handful of far-left candidates aligned with the Democratic Socialists, whom Republicans have already used to portray the party as beholden to a far-left socialist agenda. Democratic leaders have tried to head off a repeat of the Freedom Caucus problem by pairing a progressive and a centrist at the head of each policy working group.

The larger danger is overreach. Investigations that look like score-settling could squander the goodwill of the independents who delivered the majority.

Republicans offer a different reading of the election and the past two years. They argue that the administration was enforcing laws already on the books, that mass deportation was an explicit 2024 promise, and that Minneapolis reflected protest violence and isolated incidents, not policy. They note that a dissenting justice called the tariffs “clearly lawful” even if unwise, and that other statutes remain available. On Iran, they say a president’s authority as commander in chief does not pause for an election and that congressional conditions would weaken American leverage. And they point out that midterm losses are normal for the party in the White House.

What neither side disputes is that the next two years will test whether a majority built on opposition can become something more. Democrats have promised to spend their first days on health care and prices. Trump, who controls the veto, the war and the machinery of enforcement, will decide how much of that agenda survives.

Anik Rahman is a freelance contributor.