HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
Bangladesh

Much ado about nothing: Is Hasina coming or not?

Why it would indeed be surprising if Hasina actually returned at this juncture

NUTSHELL TODAY
BIONIC READING

There is a big buzz in Bangladesh about Hasina’s return. This time she has announced the month of arrival – December – loudly and proudly. This time she is not going to slip into the country, “Tuk kore” or “foosh kore” as she had earlier assured her loyalists. Nobody knows the exact auspicious time and date of her grand return, but we do know from newspaper reports that Hasina has already applied, through a law firm, for a passport and an NID. Everywhere around the country and even abroad, this is the talk of the town: at home, in secret meetings, in heated discussions, in sudden lightning street processions, and in exploding firecrackers. A few lines from Sukumar Ray comes to mind:

Thas thas drum dram shune lage khotka Phul phote tai bolo ami bhabi potka

This reference to “potka” is deliberate because I don’t think the country has ever seen Sheikh Hasina in a courageous, heroic role. She has no part in the Liberation War of 1971, she has no part in anything except in being the daughter of her father. While party stalwarts like Matia Chowdhury and others were dragged through the streets, beaten, assaulted, and imprisoned, Hasina was confined for a few days during the 1/11 period, safely and comfortably, under house arrest. When she complained of ear and eye problems, two eminent physicians recommended that Hasina be flown to the US. These two physicians were amply rewarded later. Hasina’s history of cowardice is well-documented through her timely absences.

It is impossible to believe that Hasina will return to Bangladesh while the proverbial sword of Damocles hangs over her life. She simply does not have the courage to face the consequences of her return.

For Hasina for whom even comfortable house arrest was intolerable, it is difficult to think of her willfully returning to face the real possibility of death by hanging, or at best, rotting in a “mirror room” – Aynaghar – for the rest of her life.

For the last twenty years (15+5), if we take her first five years as PM, consider the life of corruption and luxury, of limitless power that she enjoyed. Consider her expensive saris and watches, her jewelry and handbags, her multiple layers of security, the pomp and circumstance that surrounded her. Even now in exile in New Delhi, regardless of whether she is a state guest or not, she lives in considerable luxury. She may be lonely and she may long for the kingdom that she thinks is hers by birthright. But it is gone. Can she take a leap into the darkness that awaits in Bangladesh?

So what is all this noise about her return? First, there is no doubt that the possibility of her return works as a huge booster for die-hard AL supporters, workers, and leaders of AL, whether they are also in exile or hiding inside the country. The very thought of Hasina’s return is like a wet dream to her devotees.

Secondly, it is also certain that there are many sympathisers of AL both within the armed forces, within the government, and some even within BNP itself. They are all desperately waiting for an opportune moment for Hasina to re-enter the country. The perception of a weak BNP government might have led them, and Hasina, to believe that the moment has arrived.

We also cannot discount the real possibility that Hasina might have simply overstayed much beyond the honeymoon period, particularly now, with the growing agitation of the National Cockroach Party led by fearless Gen Z leaders, much like the movement in Bangladesh. It certainly gives little to benefit to India to provide indefinite protection to a fallen leader, shunned and ostracized by much of the world.

A little memory

I will now conclude this piece with a personal anecdote. In 1988, I was a consultant engineer in Brunei when one day Hasina’s sister Rehana invited me for lunch saying that her sister was visiting. My family was in Dhaka so I went alone. After initial introduction and exchange of greetings, we talked about politics and I remember talking about the necessity of forming a national government. It was clear then that Hasina would soon lead the country after the fall of Ershad. I remember talking briefly about my involvement in progressive student politics since 1962 when I was a first-year student of BUET.

I mentioned my brother-in-law, Dewan Mahbub Ali, joint secretary of NAP, a close associate of Tajuddin Ahmed, and who died of a heart attack in 1971 after returning from a tour of some European cities representing the cause of a free Bangladesh. I suddenly realised that she was not listening to me at all. Instead, she ranted endlessly about Sheikh Mujib and his party and its contribution to the nation’s independence.

At one point she rudely told me that I was lucky to be working in Brunei only because of what AL had achieved. I had to tell her bluntly that in 1971 during the Liberation War I was already in the US as a student and I could have stayed back if I wanted. Instead, I returned to the newly-liberated nation in February 1972. She followed this with a final comment which can only be said in Bangla but means roughly: enough of this tall talk.

At the end of these 3-4 hours in Hasina’s company (with Rehana as the only other person present) my lasting impression from this intimate encounter was that of a woman of limitless arrogance and intolerance. Nothing that she did – her misdeeds mostly – during her two decades surprised me.

I would indeed be surprised if she now returned.

Waheed Asghar is an engineer who worked as consultant for various national and international organizations. He now lives in Toronto.

░▒▓█▓▒░