HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
Bangladesh

The Song Remains the Same

From the Tin Joter Ruprekha to the July Charter, Bangladesh has drafted its reforms and shelved them. The usual diagnosis is weak will. The real one is incentives: reform asks the winner to give up the tools that protect it if it loses. Until losing is safe, nobody will disarm.

APURBA JAHANGIRExecutive Editor
BIONIC READING

Somewhere in Dhaka there is a cabinet shelf that deserves its own stage in the National Museum. On it sit the Tin Joter Ruprekha, the reports of 29 task forces and the 153 recommendations of a reform commission. Serious people drafted every one of them for serious governments, and then they were politely forgotten.

The shelf keeps growing, and the habits stay the same. The newest addition is the July Charter, with 84 proposals. The usual diagnosis is weak will. That makes it a problem of character, and the fix is better people. But we have tried better people. The real answer is structural: reform asks the winner to disarm, and nothing in our system pays for disarmament.

Think about what a real reform does. An independent judiciary, a neutral civil service and an Anti-Corruption Commission nobody can steer all limit whoever holds power next, and that includes you.

In opposition, this is a wonderful idea. Opposition parties adore an independent court, the way tenants adore rent control. In office, the same court is a threat. The party that signed the pledge on Monday finds on Tuesday that the police, the courts and the secretariat are exactly what it will need if it loses. After 1991 the BNP and the Awami League took turns learning this.

So the cycle isn't only hypocrisy. It is a rational reading of the game. Our politics is winner-takes-all in a literal sense. Losing has meant arrest, exile, a hollowed-out party and sometimes worse. The Awami League, which folded every rival into BAKSAL in 1975, was itself barred from the February 2026 election. The wheel turns, and the ones it crushes keep changing. A leader who builds neutral institutions in that world is betting personal safety on the goodwill of rivals. Few take that bet.

The 1972 promise went quickly for this reason. Article 47, on property rights, was the first thing amended, in 1973.

By 1975 the Fourth Amendment had swapped parliament for a presidency and folded every party into BAKSAL. It left so much power at the centre that authoritarian rule had an easy way in, and power at the centre is very hard to give back.

Fifty years and several constitutions later, the instinct has only changed party. Same song, new lead singer. Kind of like Warfaze (Big fan).

The 2026 sequence rhymes. The BNP won 209 of 300 seats, a majority so large it could amend the weather. Its MPs then declined to take a special oath as members of a constitution reform council, arguing that the constitution provides only for a legislator's oath. A parliamentary committee took over.

That is a lawyerly point. But a government with 209 seats can change the law, and the committee route happens to keep the pen in its own hand. Voters approved the July Charter with 68 per cent, and the government has found a process in which it gets to be the editor. Call it respecting the referendum with editorial discretion.

The government also resisted a consensus-based process for choosing caretaker heads. It is dropping a separate Supreme Court secretariat it once backed. Safeguards, as always, are easier to love from the other side of the table.

The opposition does not get a pass. Jamaat and its allies are boycotting the committee, which leaves the government with an empty room and the gavel. A boycott is a fine way to be right in public and irrelevant in the drafting.

Parliament is only half the machine. The other half answers its phone.

The civil service likes to play the victim. I worked close enough to the machinery to know it isn't one. Politicisation is rarely imposed on officers. It is negotiated, quietly, one posting at a time, and both sides leave the room comfortable. The minister gets a file that moves. The officer gets a desk that stays. Nobody signs anything, which is the point.

The bureaucracy is not a bystander in this dance of "democracy". It is a player, and a powerful one.

The new government promised a merit-based, apolitical service. But the pattern of appointments, postings, and promotions still follows the old patronage system. Party members now lead agencies, retired sympathisers are back, and more than a quarter of permanent secretaries are on contract. That is the Bangladesh way to depoliticise a service: replace the old loyalists with new ones and call it reform.

Nor did the caretaker period escape the pattern.

Caretakers have the legitimacy to start but not the mandate to finish. Elected governments have the mandate but just don't care enough.

Look at how we do it. A crisis arrives, a commission is formed, a report is delivered with a ceremony, and the cameras leave. Every reform on our shelf is a document. None is a schedule with a penalty attached.

The 1991–92 task forces drew on more than 250 experts, and most of their work went unread. Akbar Ali Khan, who chaired the 2007 commission, resigned in 2009 over a lack of cooperation. The reports end up trampled underfoot.

So what would break the loop?

Exhortation won't. We have asked our leaders to be better for fifty years, and the results are clear.

 The loop breaks only when a winner can lose without losing everything.

That takes four tests, and the government can pass all of them.

  1. A schedule with teeth. Publish dates for the constitutional amendments and attach a consequence to missing them. The 180-working-day deadline already exists, so let’s see what happens when it passes.
  2. Appointments everybody can live with. The Anti-Corruption Commission, the Public Service Commission and the Ombudsman should not be staffed by whoever won last. Pick their heads through a process that lets the loser trust the referee. That is how you make losing survivable, and it is the whole game.
  3. A bank review that frightens someone. Publish the real numbers, ugly ones included. Honest figures on who borrowed, who defaulted and who was protected are exactly what a winner would rather keep as leverage over a loser. If nobody in the room flinches, the review wasn't honest.
  4. A gentlemen's agreement. Every player, from the BNP and Jamaat to the parties still waiting for a seat, should agree that some lines will not be crossed. No jailing rivals as a hobby. No gutting the courts on the way out. No leaving the loser without a future. The Awami League wrecked this once by crossing every line and then a few more, and the rest of us are still paying for it.

We have never lacked the plan. We lack a politics where losing is safe enough for winning to be generous, and the 209-seat majority is the best chance in a generation to build one. Waste it, and the next government will draft a better plan, praise it warmly and lose it by lunch.

░▒▓█▓▒░