HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
World

Trump, Xi and Putin Set to Hold First Trilateral Summit on November 19

US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin are set to hold their first trilateral summit on November 19 on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China. The leaders are expected to discuss nuclear arms control, energy security and bilateral relations, although their competing interests could limit what the gathering achieves. The Ukraine war, meanwhile, is unlikely to feature formally despite Putin's interest in raising the matter.

SUNEHRA AFREENDesk Reporter
BIONIC READING

In a Nutshell

  • The White House has confirmed that Trump, Xi and Putin will meet on November 19, bringing together the leaders of three of the world's largest nuclear powers.
  • Nuclear arms control is expected to feature, following the expiration of the New START treaty in February. Trump wants a new agreement that includes China, but Beijing has resisted joining negotiations.
  • The US-Israeli war on Iran and the prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz are expected to be discussed, with China concerned about energy supplies and Russia benefiting from higher prices.
  • The Ukraine war is unlikely to be formally discussed, as Washington is pursuing a separate peace process involving Russia and Ukraine without China's participation.

Context 

Nuclear arms control is expected to be one of the main issues, following the expiration of New START between Washington and Moscow in February. Trump has called for a new agreement that would also include China, but Beijing has resisted joining negotiations, arguing that its nuclear arsenal is considerably smaller than those of the US and Russia. A senior Trump administration official has also acknowledged that the discussions are unlikely to produce an agreement.

The US-Israeli war on Iran is another issue the leaders are expected to discuss, although their interests in the conflict differ. Before the war, around one-third of China's crude oil imports passed through the Strait of Hormuz, making its prolonged closure a major concern for Beijing. Russia, meanwhile, has benefited economically from higher energy prices and recent US sanctions relief.

For Putin, the war in Ukraine would be a major topic of discussion he would be interested in bringing up at the summit. However, it is unlikely to be formally discussed. On November 10 and 11, Washington held US-mediated talks in Abu Dhabi between Russian and Ukrainian delegations as part of a separate peace process. Neither Zelenskyy nor Putin attended personally, and the talks ended without a major breakthrough, although both sides agreed in principle to a prisoner exchange.

Washington has indicated that Ukraine is unlikely to be a topic of discussion in Shenzhen because China is not involved in the separate negotiations. Other reasons Ukraine is unlikely to become a major focus of the summit stem from Europe's insistence on having a place at the negotiating table.

At a G7 foreign ministers' meeting in Paris on November 10, German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul argued that “there can be no solution without Europe, only with Europe”, after European representatives were excluded from the main Abu Dhabi talks. US envoys Witkoff and Kushner subsequently told Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on November 12 that Europe would be included in the next round of talks, although Moscow has yet to confirm this.

Why It Matters 

The summit comes at a time when all three leaders are seeking to project their influence on the international stage, despite having little common ground on the issues they are expected to discuss.

Putin stands to gain from appearing alongside Trump and Xi, particularly as he seeks to bring Russia back into high-level diplomacy despite the war in Ukraine. For Xi, hosting the gathering allows China to project an image of diplomatic influence and stable relations with Washington. Trump, meanwhile, could use the summit to bolster his image as a global leader in the aftermath of his party's crushing losses to Democrats in the November midterm elections.

The fact that Ukraine is unlikely to feature also means the summit will not provide Putin with the opportunity to discuss the war in the trilateral setting he has sought. With Washington keeping those negotiations on a separate track, the gathering is more likely to serve as a display of Russia's international standing than a forum for advancing its position on Ukraine.

What We Think 

The summit may be historic, but it risks becoming little more than a photo-op, with each leader more interested in projecting an image that reassures their own country and serves their political interests. Without a shared agenda or willingness to address their differences, the gathering is unlikely to achieve much beyond the appearance of diplomatic cooperation.

░▒▓█▓▒░