HomeEditorialsFeatureAbout UsGames
World

Historic Xi-Trump-Putin meeting ends without major breakthroughs

The first-ever trilateral meeting between US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin at the APEC summit produced a joint peace declaration but no concrete breakthroughs on nuclear disarmament or the wars in Ukraine and Iran.

3:17
Bionic
Reading

In a Nutshell

  • Trump, Xi and Putin met without other leaders on November 19, on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.
  • Their joint declaration said nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought, and pledged dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. It set no disarmament targets or timetable.
  • The declaration did not mention the wars in Ukraine or Iran, and no agreement was reached on either conflict.
  • It also called for UN reform and more refined petroleum production, and criticised the International Criminal Court’s jurisdiction.
  • North Korean leader Kim Jong-un left the summit without a meeting with Trump, despite earlier expectations.
  • On November 20, Trump called his relationships with Xi and Putin “fantastic” and said there was “great electricity” among the three leaders.

Context 

The November 19 meeting was the first trilateral gathering of the sitting leaders of the world’s three largest nuclear powers. Trump called it historic; Putin cited shared interests in resolving conflicts, while Xi urged efforts to prevent nuclear war.

Expectations of a breakthrough were low. Ukraine and European countries had warned against a settlement made without Kyiv’s involvement. China also faced diplomatic risks in putting Ukraine formally on the agenda, given its economic ties with Europe and its effort to appear neutral.

At a press conference the next day, Trump said his relationship with Putin gave the United States “additional strength”. He claimed Putin had told him Russia would not have invaded Ukraine if Trump had been president in 2022, and blamed the war’s continuation partly on hostility between Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Russia launched further attacks on Ukraine after the summit.

Why It Matters 

The three leaders came away with different gains. Putin arguably benefited most, as his participation marked a return to high-level international diplomacy after years of isolation following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The ICC support for increasing refined petroleum production and supplies offered a diplomatic endorsement of Russia's oil sector.

Xi, meanwhile, demonstrated China's ability to convene a high-profile diplomatic gathering and position itself as a major player in international affairs without making significant concessions. By accommodating Trump's interest in nuclear arms control while avoiding specific commitments, he protected China's position on its expanding nuclear arsenal.

Despite the lack of concrete agreements, Trump, at his first press conference after returning from the trip, presented his relationships with Putin and Xi as a source of strength for the US, describing the three-way meeting as a success despite the absence of substantive outcomes.

What We Think 

The outcome largely confirms what was expected of the meeting. The three leaders had reasons to benefit from being seen together, but little incentive to make concessions on issues where their interests remain fundamentally opposed. The peace declaration gives them a common position on paper, while leaving the wars and disagreements that brought them to the table unresolved. Its significance will depend on whether the commitment to nuclear risk reduction leads to further negotiations. For now, the summit has produced a historic photograph and a diplomatic statement, rather than a meaningful change in the international conflicts it was expected to address.

░▒▓█▓▒░