What Bolsnaro’s exit shares with Hasina’s flight from Dhaka
What does history and political theory teach us about leaders who flee but refuse to surrender authority?
A plane does not lie. A politician sometimes does. A day after losing Brazil’s presidential runoff to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on 26 October, Flávio Bolsonaro told his followers in a video that he had been ordered to surrender his passports and barred from leaving the country. He added that he had “never thought about leaving the country”. By Wednesday, he and his family had reached Miami.
The Nutshell
- Flávio Bolsonaro’s departure from Brazil and Sheikh Hasina’s flight from Bangladesh are different events linked by disputes over what leaving means.
- Precedents in Peru, Sri Lanka and Ukraine show that legislatures and courts can reject, verify or reinterpret a leader’s departure.
- Political actors can distort facts about where a leader went and whether an office ended, making reliable records essential.
- Democracy requires both defeated leaders who accept institutional outcomes and governments that follow fair legal procedures.
The journey in between is a study in deniability. Early reports placed him at the Argentine border town of Puerto Iguazú before dawn on Tuesday, and his campaign coordinator denied that he had gone anywhere. Argentina’s government rejected the claims, and a police source told AFP there was “no formal record” of his leaving. The uncertainty did not last. Argentina’s migration authority later said the family crossed the Tancredo Neves bridge into Misiones at 10:50 pm on Tuesday and boarded a private jet within the hour, bound for Guayaquil in Ecuador. The plane refuelled there and landed near Miami on Wednesday morning. Brazil said it had questioned Argentina over the journey, a claim Buenos Aires denies.
Then came the refinement. Bolsonaro insisted that “I did not flee Brazil”, saying he had left to protect himself and his family. Lula called the departure shameful and said Bolsonaro could have stayed to prove the accusations false. Those accusations relate to a money-laundering investigation that Bolsonaro denies.
I did not flee Brazil
A word of precision. Flávio Bolsonaro is not a president. He is a senator, the son of a former president and the defeated challenger. The presidency belongs to Lula, who has won another term. The confusion is understandable because the family has done this before. In December 2022, Jair Bolsonaro, then the sitting president, flew to Florida two days before Lula’s inauguration, skipping the handover of the presidential sash. His son’s departure was different: secretive and publicly denied. The father left like a president unwilling to attend his successor’s inauguration; the son left like a politician facing a legal investigation.
For readers in Bangladesh, the question sounds familiar. On 5 August 2024, Sheikh Hasina left Dhaka as a student-led uprising closed in and took shelter in India. Days later, her son, Sajeeb Wazed Joy, told Reuters that she had never officially resigned because “She didn’t get the time”. Weeks afterwards, in a leaked audio recording whose authenticity and timing remain unverified, Hasina was heard saying that she had left Ganabhaban under security pressure, never reached Bangabhaban to hand the President a resignation letter and therefore had not resigned. The army chief had announced her resignation on the day she left. A senior BNP leader replied that leaving at forty-five minutes notice was itself a resignation.
She didn’t get the time
The two cases are not identical. Hasina was a sitting prime minister driven out by a mass uprising. Flávio Bolsonaro was a defeated candidate who left after a Supreme Court order to surrender his passports. She disputed the formal meaning of her departure from office. He disputed the political meaning of his departure from the country. What they share is the grammar of denial. Once the movement itself is established, the argument is over what it means, and in particular whether leaving a country amounts to leaving an office or giving up a claim to legitimacy. The leader does not necessarily deny the departure. The leader denies the verb. Resigned, fled, abandoned: each word is chosen carefully because each carries a political and sometimes constitutional consequence. In Bangla, we say palano, to run away. No politician wishes to be the subject of that verb.
A bit of history on taking off
Peru offers the sharpest precedent. President Alberto Fujimori travelled to Japan amid a corruption scandal and faxed his resignation to Congress from Tokyo in November 2000. Congress refused to accept it and instead declared him morally unfit, clearing the way for Valentín Paniagua to take over. The incident was a contest over who has the authority to say when a presidency ends: Fujimori wanted to leave on his own terms, and Congress wanted the record to show a failure. He was still the sitting president, unlike Bolsonaro, yet the lesson travels that a resignation is not the final word merely because its author says so.
Sri Lanka handled it differently. Gotabaya Rajapaksa fled to the Maldives and then Singapore after protesters stormed his residence during the country’s worst economic crisis in decades in July 2022. His resignation arrived by email only after he landed in Singapore, and the parliamentary speaker first said such a message could not be accepted at face value. He accepted it only after the original letter was flown from Singapore to Colombo and its authenticity was verified. That caution mattered, because a country had to separate its president’s absence from the formal end of his office, and it did so through a recognised process.
Ukraine reversed the sequence. After Viktor Yanukovych left Kyiv in February 2014, parliament did not wait for a resignation. It adopted a resolution declaring that he had withdrawn from his constitutional powers in a non-constitutional manner and set an early election for 25 May. Yanukovych later asked a Kyiv court to invalidate it, and the court left his claim without consideration. The wording matters. The resolution recorded not that a president had travelled but that he had stopped governing.
Peru’s Congress rejected Alberto Fujimori’s faxed resignation and declared him morally unfit.
Ukraine’s parliament declared that Viktor Yanukovych had withdrawn from his constitutional powers in a non-constitutional manner.
Sri Lanka verified the original resignation letter after Gotabaya Rajapaksa sent it by email from Singapore.
Sheikh Hasina left amid a student-led uprising, while a competing narrative disputed whether she had formally resigned.
Peru, Sri Lanka and Ukraine suggest that political departure is not a single event. A legislature can reject a resignation, accept one only after verifying it, or read an absence as abandonment, and each choice answers a different question about when an office ends. Institutions decide how the departure is recorded, but the struggle over its meaning rarely ends at the border.
When the state rewrites absence
Brazil’s own history offers the mirror image. In the early hours of 2 April 1964, Congress declared the presidency vacant even though President João Goulart was still on Brazilian soil. A US diplomatic record shows the Senate president did so despite an official statement that Goulart was merely absent in Rio Grande do Sul. A new president was sworn in within hours, and a military dictatorship that would govern until 1985 acquired its constitutional cover. Goulart went into exile and died in Argentina in 1976. Congress annulled that session in 2013, nearly half a century later.
Brazil has now seen the distortion run in both directions. In 1964, the state declared that a man had left when he had not. In 2026, a man declares that he has not fled when he has crossed an international border. The first was a weapon, used by powerful institutions to dress a coup in constitutional language. The second is a shield, used by a politician to recast a departure as something other than flight. They are not equivalent, because only the first came with the power of the state behind it.
The aftermath in Dhaka shows that a dispute over words does not settle the legal question. On 17 November 2025, the International Crimes Tribunal sentenced Hasina to death in absentia over the crackdown on the 2024 uprising, in which the UN says up to 1,400 people died. The UN human rights office called the verdict an important moment for victims, reiterated its opposition to the death penalty and stressed that international fair-trial standards are particularly vital in trials held in absentia. Hasina rejected the verdict as biased and politically motivated, and India acknowledged it without announcing an extradition decision. Distance did not close her case. It postponed the argument. Whether Brazil’s proceedings will follow a similar path is unknown. What is clear is that leaving a country does not end a legal case.
What is at stake is the status of the fact itself. Hannah Arendt, in her 1967 essay Truth and Politics, distinguished factual truth from political opinion. Facts about who did what, where and when, she argued, are the very texture of the political realm. They exist beyond the preferences of political actors, yet remain vulnerable to organised distortion, which, as one Arendt scholar notes, wears away the citizen’s ability to trust politicians and hold them to account. The absence of a formal record sits at the heart of the Bolsonaro episode. When the state cannot establish a departure through its own records, the witnesses become flight-tracking data, foreign newspapers, migration authorities and an arrivals hall in Miami. Hasina’s insistence that she never resigned, set against the army chief’s announcement that she had, poses the same problem in a different form. The dispute concerns more than one senator or one former prime minister. It tests whether a society can still agree on where its political actors are and what they have done.
Facts, legitimacy, democratic restraint
Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt ask a different question: what a democracy requires of those who lose. In How Democracies Die, they argue that constitutions depend on two unwritten habits: mutual toleration, the acceptance of rivals as legitimate, and institutional forbearance, the restraint not to exploit every legal power for partisan advantage. Bolsonaro’s conduct sits uneasily with the first. He initially refused to recognise Lula’s victory and called for the election to be annulled, before promising to organise the opposition. An opposition has every right to challenge a government, question judicial decisions and organise against a winner. But democratic opposition means participating in institutions, not rejecting their legitimacy whenever they produce an unwelcome outcome. Leaving the country does not by itself breach that norm; refusing to accept the result does. The democratic loser is the one who accepts that losing an election does not end the right to compete.
Forbearance, however, is owed by winners too. The court that ordered Bolsonaro to surrender his passports and the tribunal that convicted Hasina are very different bodies acting at very different stages, but both depend on lawful procedure for their authority. The UN’s insistence on due process, particularly in trials held in absentia, makes the same point: how a state treats those who leave or are removed from office matters as much as the departure itself. A republic earns the right to demand that its fugitives return only by being a place worth returning to.
Albert Hirschman’s Exit, Voice, and Loyalty addresses the act of leaving itself. Dissatisfied members of an organisation can leave or speak from within, and loyalty is what holds exit at bay long enough for voice to work. Hirschman also observed that the easy availability of exit tends to weaken voice. A defeated candidate who promises to organise the opposition and then boards a jet has chosen exit while claiming voice. A deposed leader who insists she never resigned has chosen exit while claiming office. Fujimori tried to set the terms of his ending by fax. Rajapaksa left before surrendering office, and Yanukovych later went to court to contest the resolution on his absence. Each wanted the freedom of absence and the authority of presence. The cost falls on citizens, in Brasília, Dhaka, Lima, Colombo and Kyiv, who are asked to keep faith with leaders who are somewhere else.
A test for democracy
None of this makes leaving a crime. People flee danger, courts can err and governments can weaponise constitutional procedure. Flávio Bolsonaro has been convicted of nothing and denies wrongdoing. Hasina was convicted in her absence by a tribunal she calls biased. Fujimori was removed by Congress, and Rajapaksa’s resignation was accepted. These are different legal positions and should not be collapsed into one moral category. The narrower issue is the attempt to control the meaning of a visible event. A leader may dispute the legality of a removal, the fairness of a trial or the legitimacy of a successor. Those are proper subjects of public debate. The argument turns dangerous when it asks citizens to deny the underlying facts.
A plane does not lie. It leaves a trail on a flight tracker and a record in an arrivals hall. A resignation may be disputed, a vacancy contested and a verdict challenged. Yet democracy requires a shared commitment to establishing what happened before deciding what it means. The test for any democracy, in South America or South Asia, is whether it still insists on reading that record aloud.
Nafew Sajed Joy is a Bangladeshi researcher, writer, and environmentalist with a keen interest in sustainability, development, and South Asian affairs. He can be reached at nafew.sajed@gmail.com